Read More Link.
Download Requirement. To join us, simply download the Substack app ahead of time.
App Accessibility. Get more from Joanna Goddard in the Substack app, available for iOS and Android.
Anniversary Celebration. We’re celebrating one year of Big Salad by offering a huge giveaway of my 12 favorite things.
Engaging Topics. Come hang with writer Erika Veurink and me as we dig into friendships, dating, marriage, sex, and embarrassing stories.
Live Stream Announcement. We’re excited to host our first-ever live stream TOMORROW on the Substack app.
Graphic Zig-Zag Stripes. The zig-zaggy yellow and black stripes on this polo neck are so graphic and fun, and I dig the hit of orange at the collar.
French Vibe Cardigan. The shoulder buttons on this one from Everlane endow it with a decidedly French vibe.
Cute Wool-Cashmere. And finally, a cute wool-cashmere option that I would reach for on repeat.
Wine Shade Mock-Neck. And I like the wine shade on this mock-neck too.
Understatedly Chic Colors. The combination of colors here is just really understatedly chic.
Fun Cropped Number. The variegated stripes on this slightly cropped number are a fun touch.
Luxe Cotton-Cashmere. This Alex Mill cardi is made of a luxe-feeling cotton-cashmere blend, and I dig that the buttons go all the way to the top.
Read More. Click through to read the whole thing.
Image Details. This pair manages to look clunky and polished at the same time.
Snappy Style. I like the longer shaft and cap toe on this snappy pair.
Fashiony Choices. These are a bit more fashiony than I usually show.
Affordable Madewell Choice. This pair from Madewell mines a similar vein for cheaper.
Footwear for Comfort. If neuromas, bunions, or some other middle-aged foot maladies don’t prevent you from wearing pointy-toe boots, you could do worse than these.
Insulated Pair Preference. I also like this insulated pair for the chillier months.
Pre-Fall Dressing. Pre-fall dressing takes place now during the peak of 'Pretend it's an Editorial' weather.
Affordable Button-Downs. I am always on the lookout for good button-downs under $100, and this one seems pretty cute and crisp.
Sweater Jacket. J. Crew’s textured lady sweater jacket rings in at under $200, and is just as cute as pricier iterations from fancier brands.
Polo Neck Sweater. A snappy polo neck sweater that goes for just under $50.
Faux Fur Toggle Coat. If I hadn’t already splurged on a fall jacket, I would go for this amazing faux fur toggle coat from Kule in a flash.
Harlow Pant. It’s Madewell’s ever-popular Harlow pant, denim edition, and I’m intrigued.
Fingerless Gloves. I also ordered these fingerless gloves, the color combination of which I am enchanted by.
Knitwear Designer. I’m a big fan of UK-based knitwear designer Jo Gordon; her pieces are so colorful and happy.
Luxury Cashmere. The texture of this brushed cashmere cardi from Cos is so luxe, and the shade is a really pretty perfect grey.
Chic Leopard Print. Sezane has got quite a few I’m coveting, including this chic collarless leopard print number.
Interview Highlights. This year, Big Salad published over 30 interviews featuring various personalities sharing preferences and life advice.
Reader Favorites. Readers shared their favorite things, such as icebreakers and romantic TV shows, showcasing the engagement of the community.
Samantha Irby's Message. In the comedy issue, Samantha Irby encouraged unapologetic enjoyment of one's preferences, regardless of others' opinions.
Anniversary Celebration. Big Salad is celebrating its first birthday, marking a year since its first issue.
Giveaway Plans. A huge giveaway of favorite things will be featured in the anniversary issue landing in paid subscribers' inboxes on September 20th.
Live Chat Event. Next week, a live chat for paid subscribers is scheduled on Thursday, September 19th.
Aflalo NYC Launch. Yael Aflalo's new brand 'Aflalo' will focus on ideally shaped cashmere knits and uniquely tailored overcoats, launching later this month.
Top Winona Ryder Roles. On the occasion of the Beetlejuice sequel, here are the 20 best Winona Ryder roles, ranked.
Irving Penn Portraits. These Irving Penn portraits of people in various trades, from 1950, are just asto...
NY Fashion Week. It was fashion week here in New York, and here’s some not-entirely-wackadoo street style for you to enjoy.
Related Post. Read more
Classic Ball Clock. This classic midcentury Nelson ball clock, which I've never seen on sale, is still not cheap but might be worth it.
Fun Dot-Print Blanket. This cute and graphic dot-print blanket would be perfect for mixing and matching patterns.
Classic Dinnerware. I'm so tempted by this classic Heller dinnerware set, perfect for dining outdoors because it's made of unbreakable melamine.
Attractive Dog Bowl. A more-attractive-than-it-needs-to-be dog bowl.
Stylish Dog Bed. A fun color block dog bed that looks nice and cozy.
Elegant Menorah. Maybe the most elegant menorah I've ever seen.
Clash of Styles. I also kind of adore these brilliantly clashy bookends from Tom Dixon.
Cheerful Bookends. A quartet of bright and happy mismatched bookends.
Reasonable Pricing. This wall clock from Hay is a bit more utilitarian, and a lot more reasonably priced than the Nelson one.
Morning Shed Trend. Sara Radin explores the morning shed: 'a new trend signifying our morbid desire to be perpetually hot.'
Skin Routine Issues. Interview any dermatologist...and they will tell you the best thing you can do for your skin is simplify your routine.
Ilana Kohn's Impact. As a Brooklyn mom, I love Ilana Kohn; she’s the gateway drug to Eileen Fisher.
Non-Toxic Makeup. I swear by the non-toxic Olio e Osso stick in a watermelon-y pink shade.
Cozy Sweater Choice. You can’t do better than a men’s L.L. Bean cotton fisherman sweater — they’re really cozy.
Bad Sisters Anticipation. I can’t wait for Bad Sisters Season 2 (November 13th).
Upcoming Event. This month, we’ll be celebrating the one-year anniversary of Big Salad with a live virtual event.
Grudge Report Popularity. Her most popular Grudge Report newsletter issue was called 'Some Recipes to Make When You Lose Your Bodily Autonomy'.
Humor Writing Advice. Bess Kalb advised, 'Have something very upsetting happen to you, then, instead of processing it, deflect with jokes.'
Bess Kalb Feature. I was lucky enough to meet humor writer Bess Kalb at a dinner party last spring.
Dinner at Pilot. Last night, I met my friends Liv and Ryan for dinner at Pilot, a boat in Brooklyn that doubles as an oyster bar.
Cosmetic Surgery Language. The language around cosmetic surgery is dumbed down to make it feel like a relaxing facial, despite it involving invasive procedures.
Layering Trend. This long sleeve tissue tee from Lovechild 1979 should be worn with layers over.
Cultural Shift. I think we’re entering our butterfly era.
Favorite Author. The book I’d been reading (August Blue) by Deborah Levy reminded me why she’s one of my favorite authors.
Jessica DeFino's Influence. Jessica DeFino's newsletter 'The Review of Beauty' has been called 'the beauty industry fears'.
Emily Kirkpatrick's Work. Emily Kirkpatrick is recognized as the creator of 'I <3 Mess', a weekly roundup of celebrity fashion.
Dusen Dusen Sale. Dusen Dusen is having a sample sale, with discounts up to 70% off.
Rifle Paper Gifts. Rifle Paper is offering up to 50% off, a good moment to stock up on small gifts.
Crate & Barrel Sale. Discounts at Crate & Barrel are up to 60%—I love these chic planters.
Brooklinen Discount. At Brooklinen, everything is 25% off; I recently acquired this cushy waffle robe, and love it.
Uniqlo Popular Bag. Various items are marked down at Uniqlo, including this virally popular drawstring bag.
Ban.do Discount. The goods at Ban.do are 25% off sitewide; I always find cute things I want.
Athleta Fall Sale. Fall items are 25% off at Athleta; I’m tempted by these comfy-looking high-rise pants.
Jenni Kayne Discount. At Jenni Kayne, everything is 20% off, making this an excellent opportunity to nab some of her excellent knitwear.
Madewell Extra Discount. Madewell is offering an extra 40% off sale items, and 25% off select fall essentials.
Great Jones Offer. Great Jones is offering 25% off everything; this ceramic casserole dish is cute.
Fellow Discount. Coffee-centric site Fellow is offering 15% off most everything.
Anthro Sale. They’re offering 25% off designer denim and 40% off select home items at Anthro.
Everlane Discount. At Everlane, everything is 25% off, and I'm considering a few shirts.
Read More. For more details, refer to the article at the following link:
Dreamy Bookshop. I want to live at this idyllic bookshop in Tuscany.
Future Predictions. What the future—specifically, 2024—looked like in 1974. Some predictions came true, and others, not so much, but this is all-in-all fascinating.
Nostalgic Artifacts. These photos of vintage cassette tapes are such a fun nostalgia jolt.
Injury Indicator. A waxy, glassy, shiny forehead is incorrectly associated with a 'glow,' which it is not; it is the sign of injury.
Importance of Dead Skin. Dead skin cells serve an important biological purpose as part of the all-important skin barrier and store Natural Moisturizing Factors.
Pores Significance. Pores are outgoing channels for sebum and sweat, the skin's natural highlighter-slash-moisturizer and the body’s temperature regulator, respectively.
Glory of Glass Skin. The aesthetically inclined have been glorifying glass skin for a while, since 2017 at least—long enough that the K-beauty creation is no longer a beauty trend but a beauty standard.
Glass Skin Trend. The trend of glass skin, as claimed by a PR email, is still prevalent, with over one billion Google search results.
Desire for Acceptance. I wanted to be perfectly, evenly tan like the girls in Hawaiian Tropic ads; as softly approachable as the girls in those (really creepy in retrospect) Love’s Baby Soft ads.
Clever Drying Rack. This wall mounted clothes drying rack is one of the cleverest things I’ve seen in a while.
Utility Cart for Bar. I’d use this utility cart to set up a bar, which is a vague goal of mine.
Aesthetically Pleasing Dish. A classic Dansk casserole dish that’s just really aesthetically pleasing.
Old-School Side Table. An old-school telephone table that would work great as a sofa side table.
Marked Down Table Lamp. I’m seriously considering going for this table lamp now that it’s marked down.
Utility Stool. A cute little utility stool for the kitchen or wherever.
Cheery Dining Table. I need a new dining table rather urgently, and I’ve had my eye on this one for a while now. The bright legs make it so cheery.
Modern Bed Design. This bed—inspired by early 20th-century iron bedsteads—looks so modern in blue.
Exciting Sale. None of what’s on offer is especially cheap, which is why this sale is so exciting.
Perfect Color Match. This blue/green floral quilt would be perfect for my bedroom, as I have a large photograph in those shades hanging on the wall.
Makeup Removal. This Bioderma micellar water gets all your makeup off, and doesn’t dry out skin in the process.
Hand Sanitizer. It seems like a good idea to travel with hand sanitizer again, and this one has the most delightful (and relaxing) lavender scent.
Travel Brush. A diminutive travel brush that detangles so gently.
Makeup Setting Spray. Urban Decay All Nighter is maybe the best makeup-setting spray I’ve tried.
Miniature Preferences. I just really like a good mini, like this Sol De Janeiro body wash, which has the best caramel-ish scent.
Wrinkle Release. This Downy Wrinkle Release, which I now employ on suitcase-wrinkled clothes instead of a steamer.
Sunscreen Tint. It has the perfect tint for my skin tone.
Tinted Balm. This tinted lip balm isn’t technically a mini, but it’s pretty diminutive, and imparts a nice hit of sheer color.
Travel Razor. This Gillete Venus mini is just the cutest.
Favorite Mascara. Milk Makeup’s Kush mascara volumizes like nobody’s business and is my favorite mascara of the moment by far.
Perception Drift. DeFino states, 'When a particular beauty trend or beauty standard becomes the norm, it can affect our perception of ourselves,' a phenomenon known as 'perception drift.'
Dollcore Aesthetic. DeFino discusses the 'dollcore' aesthetic in beauty and its implications, appearing in an article for Highsnobiety.
Clinically Proven Warning. Sara Radin warns, 'Don’t fall for clinically proven beauty products,' highlighting that the medicalisation of beauty standards can promote unattainable ideals.
Naomi Watts' Book. Naomi Watts is writing a book: Dare I Say It: Everything I Wish I’d Known About Menopause.
Ideal Personal Item Bag. My personal item bag will be the Luka Duffel from Calpak—an ideal bag, with plenty of pockets, a shoe compartment, and an appealingly puffy design.
Summer Dress Choice. For warmer days, I’ll bring my perfect, and deeply flattering Universal Standard Shirt Dress.
Silk Tee Preference. A washable stretch silk tee that doesn’t look like the most exciting piece, but that I think I’ll wear on repeat.
Essential Scarf. I never travel without my silk and cashmere scarf from Chan Luu—it’s the perfect combination of lightweight and warm.
Best No-Show Socks. These are the best no-show socks I’ve found—the material is substantial, and they don’t slip.
Bringing Versatile Shirts. I’ll be bringing two of this, my favorite button-down, from the brand Cali Dreaming.
Source Link. Read more.
Podcast Transcript. here's the transcript.
Vivian Maier's Impact. Her work was discovered in 2007, and now she is considered one of the great photographers of the 20th century.
Philosophical References. The name Sublime references what philosophers Immanuel Kant and Edmund Burke considered the height of aesthetic experience.
Fragrance Market Growth. Both the premium and mass markets saw double-digit growth year-on-year in 2023, and today, the global sector is worth an estimated $68.9 billion.
New Scent Release. Tory Burch released a new scent this week: Sublime.
Read More. For additional insights, read more at the provided link.
Cashmere Sweater Purchase. Most recently it was this cashmere sweater from Organic by John Patrick, a brand I love for its knitwear.
Layering Option. A cute poplin popover for wearing on its own now, and under a blazer later.
Busty Fit. I feel like this one from Universal Standard would be especially good for the busty among us—the brand always seems to do a good job at that.
Versatile Shirt. A crisp striped colorblock shirt that rings in at just a hair over $75.
Half-Tucked Style. An oversized option that would look good half-tucked—a styling trick that seems to have fallen out of favor, but which I still like.
Crisp Style Preference. I like the preppy crispness of this one from Everlane.
Subtle Chic. The tuxedo details here are quite subtly chic.
Quality Red. It’s not always easy to locate a truly good red, and this is a good red.
Feminine Touch. The ruffle details here don’t overwhelm, but instead are a nice, feminine touch.
Cute Gingham. And finally, how delightfully cute is this gingham option?
Dog-centric Fashion. Dolce & Gabbana introduced Féfée, an 'elegant dog perfume,' while Vogue published a series of 'Dogue' covers featuring dogs in place of models.
Consumer Product Integration. A recent collaboration from skincare brand Dr. Loretta and clothing brand LESET features a monogrammed shirt designed to hold sunscreen, with 'SPF' embroidered instead of initials.
New Beauty Products. In 2022, actress Courtney Cox launched Homecourt, a line of dish soaps, surface cleaners, and candles, described as 'beauty products for the home.'
Personal Style. Ashley C. Ford mentioned her fall uniform includes a combination of Target items and personal accessories.
Postpartum Outfit Reflection. It inclined my own going for it, never mind the hurrah; this dress from Natori is the same color, but this silhouette feels more wearable.
Ralph Lauren Partnership. I partnered with Ralph Lauren last week on 2 back to school Instagram posts.
Edifying Pelosi Interview. I found this interview with Nancy Pelosi to be quite edifying. The piece is by New Yorker editor in chief David Remnick, who pulls few punches.
Explore More Links. Read more.
New Book Started. I just started reading An Hone…
Jamie Lee Curtis Interview. A fun, quick Q&A with Jamie Lee Curtis.
Cate Blanchett's Best Roles. The 40 best Cate Blanchett performances—here she is in Bob Dylan drag in the brilliant 2007 Todd Haynes movie I'm Not There.
Podcast Guest. We had a guest on the podcast earlier this year who talked about energy v…
Racial Body Image. Light is feminine in the western mind and dark is masculine, and that binary logic tends to hold serious implications for Black and other ethnic women.
Silk Scrunchie Preference. I like these silk ones though, because they're a lot thinner than your typical scrunchie, and the silk means they're easy on your hair.
Daily Sunscreen Habit. This sunscreen is not too heavy and goes on sheer but lightly tinted.
Chub Rub Solution. This stuff combats the dreaded chub rub, and I am impossibly devoted to it.
Platform Sandals Choice. I can’t believe I was ever on the fence about going for these platform Birkenstocks.
Light Summer Scent. Bum Bum Cream absorbs in a flash and smells like a dream, which makes it suitable for summer.
Effective Mascara. Better Than Sex is such an annoying name for a mascara, but it *is* a really good mascara.
Polka Dot Dress. This fairly splurgy polka dot number is nicely feminine but far from prissy.
Cotton Twill Dress. An easy cotton twill shirt dress that goes for just a hair under $50.
Retro Vibe. This has a slightly retroish vibe that I appreciate.
Versatile Shirtdress. A snappy and versatile little shirtdress.
Smocked-Front Dress. A cool smocked-front dress with a very flattering silhouette.
Summery Frock. Just a fun and very summery frock from Farm Rio.
Pintucked Details. The pintucked details at the waist make this one standout.
Loud Tiered Dress. The print on this tiered dress is loud, it's true, but I think it's loud in a really good way, and I love the blue and brown color combo.
Faux Wrap Dress. I don't love the belt they've styled this faux wrap dress with, but I do really like the fun print, and I think it drapes really nicely.
Ukrainian Fashion Emergence. To my point about sheer, you know who else started making clothes is the Ukrainian jewelry brand that makes the silver shell comb.
Online Style Influence. I came across Michelle Phanh’s Substack last weekend. She made a post about what her friends wore at a beach town in Connecticut.
Discover More. Deb reveals 10 surprises and delights, including her most popular recipe and a dreamy vacation spot for kids.
Iconic Album Covers. The stories behind six iconic album cover shots, and how to recreate them.
Greatest Sports Movies. The 50 greatest sports movies of all time.
Olympic Athletes' Bling. Olympic athletes and their bling.
Trend Immortality Query. Can a trend become immortal?
Read More Link. For further insights, visit the original source.
Fun Pouf. Such a graphic and fun little pouf.
Side Table Statement. A small side table like this can make a pretty big statement.
Pleasing Mug Design. There’s something so pleasing to me about the shape of this mug—it looks like you could warm your hands on it.
Guest Bathroom Towels. If I had a guest bathroom, and perhaps some day I will, I’d stock it with these Turkish tassel towels.
Indoor/Outdoor Pillow. An indoor/outdoor pillow that comes in a few good shades; I’m partial to this yellow, of course.
Chic Kitchen Towels. These chic kitchen towels come in such a delightful range of colors and stripe iterations.
Bath Mat Love. Also from Dusen Dusen: this cool bath mat, which is loitering in my shopping cart even as I type.
Striped Towels. Dusen Dusen can always be relied upon to offer a good striped towel or two, and I’m especially fond of these bright and happy ones.
Tonal Stripes Bowls. And finally, I dig the subtle tonal stripes on these bowls.
Botox in Politics. Cosmetic dermatology is on the rise in Washington, D.C.
Ugly Republicans Ad. A new commercial from Democratic group Won't PAC Down portrays MAGA Republicans who want to limit access to abortion, birth control, and IVF as conventionally ugly.
Beauty as Ethical Ideal. Has anyone articulated beauty as an ethical ideal better than comedian Alan Resnick?
Denim Pants Comfort. These denim pants look like slouchy perfection, and I appreciate that they have belt loops.
Stylish Sneakers. I’m so totally sold on the excellent color combination on this sneaker.
Quality Striped Shirt. Just a really good striped button-down shirt to add to my menagerie of striped shirts.
Clean Denim Appeal. I just love how un-distressed the denim on this jacket is, and the starchy clean silhouette is appealing too.
Versatile Dress. I’d wear this cute bandana print dress on its own now, and with boots, tights, and a cardigan later.
Lightweight Bomber. A really smart linen cotton cropped bomber that’s appealingly lightweight.
Track Pants Choice. For the latter I’m considering this classic pair of Adidas track pants.
Aversion to Cowboy Boots. I find myself actually pretty tempted by these cowboy boots, which are nicely subdued and yes, even cool.
Referencing Other Styles. Jenny Walton published a series of 20 ways to style a silk scarf.
Sophisticated Barn Jacket. This barn jacket is made of crinkle nylon, which gives it a more sophisticated look.
Striped Duvet Cover. I've wanted this striped duvet cover forever, and just might go for it now.
Bright Cotton Coverlet. A bright and happy cotton coverlet.
Schoolhouse Lamp. Home brand Schoolhouse has marked down many tempting items, starting with this fun, poppy table lamp.
Classic Scoopneck Swimsuit. A scoopneck swimsuit that couldn't be a lot more classic.
Versatile Cashmere Cardigan. This cashmere patch pocket cardigan comes in a few arguably more versatile colors, but I like this forest-y green.
Cool Gauze Popover. An easy and cool—both literally and figuratively—gauze popover.
Smocking Sundress. I really dig the smocking and adorable strawberry print on this sweet sundress.
Perfect Weight Jacket. This textured cotton lady jacket looks like it's the perfect weight for the transitional weather we'll be having soon.
Versatile Linen Skirt. A cute and deeply versatile linen slip skirt.
J.Crew Sale Item. At J. Crew, I'm thinking about going for this stretch linen blazer—it looks really smart in this off-white.
Shopping Strategy. I created a secret Pinterest board called ‘Should I Buy This?’ My rule is that an item has to live there for at least two weeks before I make a purchase.
Multipurpose T-shirt. Their trash tee is made with 100% post-industrial cotton waste, and the slightly longer sleeve and overall length are perfect.
Unique Design Book. Actually useful coffee table book: How to Live With Objects is a cool take on a design book that features stories of people’s spaces that help you become an intentional collector of objects that speak to you.
Drugstore Favorite. I’ve used CoverGirl Lash Blast Fusion since I was a teenager. The brush is really easy to wrap around your eyelashes to get that curled look.
Olympic Sketches. 17 classic SNL sketches about the Olympics.
Iconic Beauty in France. A look at France's iconic beauty Marianne, and the women who have portrayed her over the years.
Cheating in Older Women. Why more women over 50 are cheating.
Community Connections. Five ways to make community connections.
TV Preview. A look at the best of what's on TV this month.
Olympics Notable Moments. And here are some notable moments from the Olympics so far.
Reduced Sexual Function. One study... found Botox treatment was associated with both reduced emotional recognition and reduced sexual function.
Further Reading. Read more about the experience at the provided link.
Chanel Miller Favorites. Chanel Miller told us about her favorite pants of all time, hilarious things kids say, and the life advice Oprah gave her directly.
Finding Love Post-Divorce. I found someone lovely. Thank you so much for providing a safe space to talk about this stuff.
Catherine Newman's Influence. What a relief it is to hear 'this part of parenting is my favorite' from anyone with kids older than me. It helps me unclench.
Discount Offer. We’re also offering a 20% off discount on subscriptions this week.
Catherine Newman Joys. Catherine Newman revealed 12 things for a joyful life, including icy swims and Paul Rudd.
Lil Mama's Lipgloss. Lil Mama debuted her first-ever lipgloss line called 'It's Poppin'.
Scentbird CEO. Scentbird CEO noted, 'I'd be surprised if my investors knew,' and that they 'know my character.'
Consumer Trends Report. The podcast referenced 'Consumer Trends: 2024 Mid-Year Report' from The New Consumer.
Lily Allen's Content. Lily Allen launched an OnlyFans page to sell feet pictures.
Demi Lovato's Song. Demi Lovato released a (very catchy) song for haircare brand OGX.
Fashion Recommendation. These knotted gold sandals are about as fabulous as flats get.
Versatile Dress. A subtly glamorous watercolor print dress that’ll be as good in the fall as it will be right now.
Good Details. So many good details on this sweet embroidered shirt—I don’t even mind the puffy sleeves because the puffiness does not originate at the shoulder.
Stylish Cardigan. This knit cardigan resembles far pricier ones from the French brand Ba&sh.
Unique Shirt. A henley tee that manages to be tomboyish and sexy at the same time.
Perfect Skirt. It’s got simple lines, a bit of stretch, trouser styling, and the ability to pair with just about any top.
Un-Distressed Jeans. I really dig that these straight jeans are so delightfully un-distressed.
Weekly Discount Offered. We’re also offering a 20% off discount this week.
Favorite Jewelry Brand. Catbird, always and forever.
Documentary Trailer. The trailer for this Elizabeth Taylor doc looks pr…
Tour Participation. I’m joining my husband Paul on the tail end of his tour next week.
Link to Full Story. Read more
Under $80 Option. A handsome under $80 option from Quince that comes in a few other good shades.
Poppy Orange Tote. A poppy orange option that’s plenty roomy, from Clare V.
Filson Tote. This classic Filson tote is just cool as hell. It’s marketed to men, but honestly who cares?
L.L. Bean Tote. I can’t not include L.L. Bean’s Boat and Tote, because it’s timeless and sturdy, and comes in a variety of sizes and colors.
Time for a Tote. A fun yellow striped tote, because who doesn’t need one of those?
Baggu Duck Bag. Baggu’s Duck Bag is very well-priced, well-made, and roomy as can be. It also comes in several good prints.
Elegant Leather Trim. This isn’t cheap, but it’s so damned elegant. I also love how leather trim looks on a canvas bag.
Optimizing Shopping. Using buyback programs like Croissant has the potential to make consumers smarter and more conscious shoppers.
Shopping Experience. Croissant is an extension that follows users through commerce websites and calculates buyback prices for items they like.
Terry Option Appeal. Here's a cute and pricey terry option that I kind of love for its slightly retroish vibe.
Gauze Shirtdress Versatility. A gauze shirtdress that would work equally well off the beach.
Textured Cotton Appeal. Such a pretty, cool-looking textured cotton option.
Fun Tassels. I do enjoy the fun tassels here, and this one comes in a few other good shades.
Versatile Sarong. A sarong is always a snappy (and versatile) choice.
Affordable Gauze Caftan. This gauze and lace caftan has such good details, and is currently marked down to just under $50.
Oversized Shirt Choice. An easy oversized shirt that I also like in this pink.
Floral Sundress Highlight. This block print floral sundress couldn't be a lot prettier, and—because I am not a big fan of tiers—I like that this only has one.
Question Submissions. You can submit questions using this short form, if you’d like — all topics welcome, including love, parenting, friendships, anxiety, food, travel, NYC, books, movies, style, Paul Mescal’s short shorts, whatever!
Upcoming AMA. This week, we’re doing another Ask Me Anything!
Affordable Stylish Frames. Gabriel & Simone is a Brooklyn-based brand that churns out frames that look lots pricier than they are, like this rounded cat-eye, which rings in under $50.
Cheap Glasses Solution. And here’s a super-cheapo bonus resource for those who misplace their glasses constantly: Amazon, where this three-pack goes for a mere $16.
Well-Priced Classic Frames. Look Optic has a comparatively small number of frames on offer, but they’re pretty classically appealing and well-priced: I like this pair because the lenses are ever so slightly tinted, which can be flattering to aging eyes.
Popular Daily Frames. The pair I wear most every day—and which you guys routinely ask me about—are these, from Warby Parker.
Age-Positive Brand. I really like Caddis; the brand is very age-positive, and their frames—like these—are the just-right amount of cool.
Growth of Cosmetic Category. Amazon's cosmetic category is forecasted to grow 26% YoY in 2024, outpacing Amazon's overall growth of 19.9%.
Beauty Sales Growth. The percentage of beauty sales increased by 16% during Prime Day 2024, with makeup growing by 30% and skincare by 14%.
Environmental Impact. Prime Day likely accounted for more than 1.2 million tonnes of carbon dioxide emissions.
Worker Injuries. Estimated 45% of Amazon warehouse workers were injured during Prime Day.
Sales Surge. Amazon Prime Day 2024 netted $14.2 billion in sales.
Further Reading. For more depth on this topic, refer to the original article.
Best TV Shows. The 20 best TV shows of the year so far.
Bummer News. This really bummed me out…
Glynnis MacNicol Appearance. We've got author Glynnis MacNicol on Everything is Fine this week and she's a pip, so please do tune in.
Donald Sutherland Tribute. RIP to the endlessly cool (and hot!) Donald Sutherland.
Block Print. Here's what I found, starting with this cute block print number.
Classic Caftan. And finally, here's a pretty classic one from Emerson Fry.
Beach-to-Street Caftan. This is maybe the perfect beach-to-street caftan.
Subtle Check Print. A cool black caftan, with a subtle tonal check print.
Elegant Stripes. And I really dig this elegant linen striped one as well.
Bold Stripes. Bold blue stripes make a very summery statement.
Geometric Print. I think this geometric print is impossibly chic, and right now it's marked down from very splurgy to just kind of splurgy.
Ikat Print. A cool and graphic ikat print.
Additional Reading. Read more
Amusing Movie. This movie looks quite amusing.
Going Gray. How to go gray?
Stressful Restaurant Shows. Here are the best restaurant shows, ranked by stressfulness.
Fun Live Episode. It’s our live NYC episode on Everything is Fine this week and it’s a ton of fun, so please do tune in.
Worthwhile Movie. This movie looks worthwhile.
Perfect Summer Neutral. The light brown is a rather perfect summer neutral, especially with the white soles.
Stocking Up on Tees. I like to swing by the Nordstrom Rack site and stock up on these James Perse tees, which they always have in stock for much less cash than retail.
Surprising Chic Pieces. I’m often pleased and surprised at the chic pieces I find there, like this A-line twill skirt.
Ruching at Sleeves. The ruching at the sleeves of this dress makes it seem kind of Maria Cornejo-ish.
Elegant Flowy Dress. This flowy dress is not my typical thing, but I think it’s just so elegant, and the chain print is aces.
Urgent Sunglasses Purchase. I tried these on and paid for them before I really had a chance to register whether they looked good or not.
More Affordable Option. Here’s a more straightforward option that’s much cheaper.
Blue Striped Button-down. I dig the variegated stripes on this one.
Fashionable Dress Insight. I found this dress on the Cos website marked way down—I think it’s probably from their most recent fall/winter collection—and the shape is just so good.
Deluxe Cotton-Silk Caftan. I don't know how I'm not supposed to purchase this extremely deluxe-looking cotton-silk blend caftan.
Skirt Coveting. I’m very much coveting this silk satin skirt from 6397.
Silk Shirt Dress. This silk shirt dress is exactly what I’m talking about.
Unexpected Purple Hue. If you cover up the bad gray leggings with your hand, you can see it’s actually a pretty cool shirt, and the purple hue is nicely unexpected.
Breezy Maxi Dress. A maxi dress from Banana Republic that looks like the personification of breeziness.
Lightweight Beach Footwear. I like these synthetic Birkenstocks for wearing to the beach: they’re lightweight, waterproof, and cost about half as much as traditional Birkenstocks.
Personalizable Water Bottle. A water bottle that 'll keep your cold drinks nicely cold, and which is personalizable.
Beach Bag Choices. L.L. Bean's Boat and Tote, which comes in many sizes and strap colors, is a pretty peerless choice.
Cost-Effective Towels. I prefer happy-but-inexpensive choices like these beach towels that get trashed so fast.
Stylish Cover-Up. And finally, a crisp—and kind of sexy—cover-up.
Cost-Effective Hat. Here’s another cute hat that costs about half as much as the one above.
Fun Sun Hat. Such a fun sun hat, in an excellent yellow.
Preferred Sunscreen. I apply and frequently reapply Kosas' lightly tinted Dream Beam—it also stands in for foundation this time of year.
Effective Water Shoes. These unstylish-but-effective water shoes are a must for stepping on the rocky, slimy ocean floor.
Airy Placket Top. An airy, roomy placket top that comes in a few good shades.
Versatile Batwing Top. A batwing top that’d work as well in the fall as it does now.
Deep Neckline Popover. I like the deep neckline on this gauze popover.
Textured Shirt. A textured shirt for throwing on with jeans—or shorts, if you’re brave.
Embroidered Beach Top. This linen embroidered top would be excellent for the beach and beyond.
Sheer Printed Layer. A sheer printed top that I’d layer over a silk cami.
Oversized Striped Shirt. A good striped shirt that’s nicely oversized.
Easy Popover. Just a really easy popover for wearing whenever.
Smocked Neckline Top. I like the smocked neckline on this crisp top.
Adorable Swing Top. my friend Ann bought it and was wearing it the other day when we got together, and it is really just so adorable IRL.
Personalizable Options. Here are two cute block print options that are also personalizable.
Elegant Toile Option. This toile option is both roomy and elegant.
Bold Stripes Appeal. Bold stripes are always a win.
L.L. Bean Hanging Bag. A handy hanging bag from L.L. Bean with zillions of compartments.
Intriguing Drawstring Bag. This drawstring bag really intrigues me—unfurl it and it’s like a portable vanity for your hotel room.
Tortoise Color Combo. I like the tortoise color combination here.
Baggu Alternative. This one from Baggu comes in a pretty close second in the cuteness department.
Cute Longchamp Bag. This Longchamp bag is just the cutest.
Clear Bag Recommendation. This clear bag fits all those specs, and comes in three sizes and multiple colors.
Quilt Design. I do love the block print on this one.
Geometric Throw. A bright and happy geometric-patterned throw.
Bright Storage Baskets. A trio of happy, bright storage baskets—I'm especially enamored of the yellow and black one.
Stylish Feeding Stand. This Lucite feeding stand—with glass bowls—is maybe the most stylish way to feed a pet I’ve ever seen.
Incense Holder. Just a really neato incense holder.
Stylish Beach Chair. The cutest beach chair maybe ever. It comes in a few other color combinations.
Rug Collection. My favorite purveyor of rugs, Aelfie, went on sabbatical a while back, which made me sad.
Vintage Mugs. These vintage mugs—from a long-gone brand called Franci Villa Vanilla—are so damned cute.
Chic Flatware. This very chic flatware set is from the same collaboration.
Napkin Set. This mismatched napkin set, which is so far up my alley, is from a collaboration between West Elm and chef Marcus Samuelsson.
Read More.
Notable Obits. I love the New York Times obits, because I'm always learning about notable women I'd never heard of before—in this case, music industry vet Mary Martin.
Possible Sequel. There will apparently maybe be a Devil Wears Prada sequel.
Tribute to Duvall. RIP Shelly Duvall, who was always a favorite of mine; here's a tribute to her quirky talents.
Utility Pants. These utility pants have the just-right amount of stretch without looking like they have stretch, which is the goal.
Pretty Eyelet Caftan. Such a pretty eyelet caftan; it’s a bit sheer, but comes with cotton voile slip.
Clare V Bags. I've owned this Clare V bag in black for a few years now, and then I was gifted the green version on my birthday back in March.
Lightweight Cargo Pants. Lightweight jersey cargo pants—they're back, people, if you dare—that I think would be perfect for travel.
Shirt Dress Restock. I recently bought this poplin shirt dress—which I've already owned and loved in blue. It was sold out in my size in the black for a while, but they restocked and I was able to snag it.
Frank & Eileen Sale. There is a big sale going on at Frank & Eileen in celebration of the brand’s 15th anniversary, and all sorts of items that they never put on sale are currently marked down.
Spill-Proof Containers. After much trial and error, I have determined that these silicone containers are the best for transporting products that don’t come in a mini size.
Portable Fan Importance. When I was in Spain last summer it was dreadfully hot, and I bought a fan like this one from a tourist kiosk, and it really makes a difference.
Effective Mini Sunscreen. I love a travel-sized beauty product, especially when it's my favorite, lightly tinted sunscreen, which provides just enough coverage to make it a nice alternative to foundation when it's hot out.
Lightweight Travel Suitcase. As for suitcases, I’m loyal to Away's Bigger Carry On—it fits a lot and doesn't weigh much.
Link to Full Story.
Podcast Recommendation. Tune in to my chat with Jenn on Everything is Fine this week; it's…
Books on Appalachia. Here are 15 books about Appalachia that aren't Hillbilly Elegy.
Trump's 2025 Plan. Inside Trump's plan for 2025: this is a chilling but important read.
Marimekko Prints Database. This online database of Marimekko prints is your rabbit hole of the day; you're welcome.
Second-Hand Shopping. The author mentions only shopping second-hand and praises the vintage pieces available on sites like The Real Real.
Incredible Rice. I got a jar of award-winning white rice and will report back on how it tastes.
Collaboration Launch. Staud and Keds launched a collaboration on Friday of the classic lace up sneakers.
Keds Collaboration. It appears that Staud's Keds collab, which was highlighted in the last letter of rec is avail on the Keds site at more competitive pricing.
North American Style Shift. Half way through making that post, I realized I was sitting on what's become a 5th season uniform template, or a good way to get out of the jeans and button down rut.
Spring Basics Post. Tuesday's post broke down 5 solid spring basics and offered unconventional ways to wear them.
Comfortable Maternity Jeans. These jeans from the Scandinavian brand Ilouity have no stretch in the denim, but are so nice and roomy on the waist.
Prada Skirt Availability. This Prada skirt, avail on Re-see, is kind of like the orange one with a tail that I keep wearing, but more reasonable (chiefly because it does not have a tail).
Jelly Shoe Alternatives. I think these, specifically in blue, might be a good alt to jelly shoes if you’re not hot on the trend, but yearn for an off-shoe choice.
Airy Summer Shirt. There is no airier solution to the summer button down than Q House of Basic's 'Dennis' shirt.
Prada's Influence. These are exactly the short pants or long shorts you need in order to scratch the forthcoming itch imposed by Prada's $5,700 silk knickers.
Boring Girl Summer. I haven't been able to stop thinking about Lauren Marie's "Boring Girl Summer" since I read it in June.
Tresse x Cafe Leandra Launch. TRESSE X CAFE LEANDRA IS HERE.
Postpartum Fashion. I think this [Kapsul top] could be the postpartum hooray.
MNZ x J. Crew Collab. MNZ's J. Crew collab is all about the scrunchie for me.
Tod's Bag Comeback. It's time for the Tod's bag comeback.
Kapsul Brand. I encountered this brand, Kapsul, earlier this week thanks to a DM from the founder, Mar.
Survey Invitation. I put together an anonymous poll that you can take here.
Cultural Reference. I’m hoping participation is as robust as the bush on Gustave Courbet’s L’Origine du monde model.
Anonymous Participation. Anyone of any gender or sexual orientation is encouraged to take the survey.
Social Media Trend. 'Outfit of the day' posts on social media are slowly being replaced by 'scent of the day' posts (#sotd).
Emotional Marketing. Charlotte Tilbury's new 'emotion-boosting' fragrance More Sex is designed to enhance feelings of sex, reflecting a marketing trend towards emotional experiences.
Fragrance and Identity. Jean Madar, chairman and CEO of InterParfums Inc, recently stated that fragrance is part of a person's 'core identity'.
Fragrance Industry Surge. Perfume sales are surging in both prestige and niche categories this year.
Novel Recommendation. I suggest you pre-order this very strange, very stirring novel right now.
Challengers Film. Who else noticed the suspiciously lingering shots of Tashi's blue jar of Augustinus Bader Body Cream?
Skincare Addiction Data. Subscribers to a popular Reddit thread, r/SkincareAddiction, increased more than 60% in the past year.
Interesting Topics Covered. In this issue: Equinox pivots to skincare! Veneer tech horror stories! The other meaning of natural beauty! Like I said over a year ago: Ozempic is the new Botox!
Panel at a Philosophy Festival. I will be part of a panel on the politics of beauty and giving a solo talk on divesting from the beauty industry.
Carry On Shampoo Design. Carry On shampoo 'primarily comes in a large jug with a handle that makes it easy to carry around' and 'fills its own void' with a tiny elliptical travel-size version of itself.
Children's Concerns. Data shows that children as young as five worry about being ugly, and seek to make themselves more attractive according to the dominant ideal.
Grooming Statistics. Of the straight women polled, 82% remove some of their pubic hair — but only 15% say they’re completely bare down there.
At-Home Grooming Risks. Even if you’re fine with those risks and meet those requirements, Dr. Reed says you should get 'a proper assessment by a trained professional' before trying it at home.
Worries About Judgement. 65% of women report worrying about whether new male partners will judge their pubic hair style.
Male Preferences. 50% of men say they have no preference whatsoever when it comes to pubic or bum hair.
Pubic Hair Trends. The long-awaited results of The Pubic Hair Poll, answered by 14,000+ people, indicate that the bush is back.
Holecare Launch. A month later, Megababe founder Katie Sturino announced the launch of a new 'butthole cleanser.'
SEO Slug Insight. Brennan Kilbane wrote '‘Holecare’ Is Here. Do We Need It to Be?' for Allure. (The SEO slug? 'how-to-care-for-butthole.')
Mentioned Media Links. Media we mentioned include articles about pubic hair grooming and hair trends, highlighting the relevance of personal grooming in celebrity culture.
Republican Women's Image. Republican women are making themselves over to appeal to current U.S. presidential candidate, convicted felon, and former beauty pageant owner Donald Trump.
Cancer Linkages. Hair relaxers have been linked to reproductive disorders and cancers, and particularly aggressive forms of breast cancer are more common in Black women than in other women.
Luxury Anti-Aging Gatherings. Anti-aging enthusiasts Bryan Johnson and Kim Kardashian gathered for a 'Don't Die Dinner.'
Steroid Users Growth. The second-fastest growing population at needle exchange programs after steroid users—who now outnumber heroin and crack users—are allegedly people injecting themselves with illegal Botox and filler.
Book Recommendation. There is so much in this book about how beauty culture shows up in literary spaces too, and I really can’t recommend it enough.
Katy Perry's Video. In a clip from the forthcoming music video for her single “Woman’s World,” Katy Perry takes six jade rollers to the fully-made-up face.
Skincare Recognition. Elizabeth Banks is set to star in 'Skincare,' a campy thriller about an aesthetician launching her own beauty line, indicating a recognition of modern skincare as entertainment rather than care.
Wasteful Merch. Free gifts with purchase are getting out of control, with companies like Glossier and Versed giving away items that encourage overconsumption.
Selfies & Lice. A researcher with the Pest and Insecticide Research Center in Buenos Aires states that selfies are 'a significant transmission source' for head lice, as pressing your head to fit into a cellphone frame could facilitate transmission.
Rise of Mewing. Gabriel Smith writes in The Paris Review that Mike Mew and his father believe that in humanity there is currently an epidemic of ugliness, and they promise you can build a strong jawline through 'mewing.'
Cindy Crawford's Influence. Cindy Crawford is an “entrepreneurial role model among aspiring supermodels,” with her beauty brand, Meaningful Beauty, cited as the blueprint for model-founded cosmetic companies today.
Ramses' Beauty Routine. David Yi writes in Pretty Boys that “Every morning before sunrise, Ramses the Great would open his eyelids to find dozens of officials, servants, assistants, and slaves waiting to guide him through his elaborate beauty routine.”
Boyfriend Blush. ‘Boyfriend blush’ is a newly-popular application technique that 'replicates the outdoorsy effect of ruddy cheeks after a game of rugby or polo.'
Boxers Trend. Amazon confirms women’s boxers are 'Trending Now' as Miu Miu and Bally sent boxers down the runway for Spring-Summer 2023.
Aesthetic Trends. 2023 saw an endless stream of trends signaling the popularity of girl culture, as named 'the year of the girl' by NPR.
Viral Series Impact. In the viral TikTok series Boy Room, comedian Rachel Coster explores the dirty, disorganized, and otherwise adolescent bedrooms of adult men in New York City.
See Full Advice. The rest of my answer includes...what this woman should say to her mother.
Elective Surgery Warnings. The world will value or devalue your child based on how well they adhere to a narrow standard of beauty, and you want the best for them.
Supportive Friend. The only reason it happened is because my friend saw the possibilities in me before I could see them myself.
Request for Recommendations. For a future issue of Big Salad, please use this short web form to tell us about something you love.
Newsletter Launch. DeFino launched her newsletter to gain editorial freedom to write about the beauty industry's impact without fear of pushback.
Influential Reads. DeFino recommends James Hamblin's 'Clean' and Tressie McMillan Cottom's 'Thick' for insights on beauty and its societal implications.
Romance Novel Impact. Reading romance novels has helped me form new associations with physical intimacy.
Travel Essential. Anker power strip creates connections among strangers in an airport terminal during delays.
Family Meal Solution. Gotham Greens Vegan Pesto is a dinner hack that satisfies different dietary preferences in my family.
Sun Protection Review. Supergoop's Glow Oil spreads well and leaves your skin glowing without stickiness.
Jeans Discovery. For my 50th, my husband bought me painter pants that transform how I feel about clothing during perimenopause.
Party Snack Success. 'The Dip' by Alison Roman is the best party snack that never disappoints.
Reader Engagement. We asked readers to reveal their favorite things and received 400 responses!
Kids' Drawing Tools. Stabilo three-in-one pencils are great for kids; they are chunky enough and come in vibrant colors.
Reader Community Thanks. Thank you to everyone who wrote in! We adore this community so much.
Dating Update. I recently went on a date to an old-school steakhouse in Staten Island that was filled with nostalgia.
Simple Pleasures. Noticing nature waking up in spring is a beautiful reminder of the season's change.
Artistic Gift Recommendation. Tucker Nichols' project 'Flowers for Sick People' dedicates paintings with empathy and warmth.
Surprising Experience. Honestly, Jessica, I've been really surprised by...
Book Release. Aimee Nezhukumatathil's new book, 'Bite By Bite: Nourishments and Jamborees,' features 40 short essays focusing on different foods.
Popular Brand Recommendation. ONE particular swimsuit brand was recommended a million times by Big Salad readers.
Deep Connections. Friendships between women are often the deepest and most profound love stories, but they are often discussed as if they are ancillary, 'bonus' relationships to the truly important ones.
Ilana Glazer's Film. Her hilarious movie Babes comes out today (!) and is an INCREDIBLE ode to female friendship.
Favorite Sandwich Shop. Erin believes that Court Street Grocers in Brooklyn has the best vegetarian sandwiches.
Recommended TV Show. Erin enjoys watching the tender show 'Somebody Somewhere' with her husband, finding comfort in its portrayal of everyday life.
Moisturizing Salve. For skin care, Erin uses Lauren's All-Purpose Salve daily on her face, stating it's soothing and smells lovely, like lavender and patchouli.
Hair Care Recommendation. Erin uses Conscia shampoo and conditioner stones, which she praises for feeling incredible on her hair and having worked well for over two years.
Craft Projects Book. Erin Boyle co-wrote a book titled 'Making Things' with Rose Pearlman, filled with beginner-friendly craft projects you can create using simple materials.
Erin Boyle's Apartment Tour. Erin Boyle's apartment tour includes the #1 product she swears by for small space living.
Travel Inspiration. Reader Aja Barber shared her experience visiting sea pools in Australia after being inspired by a photo book.
Reader Experience. A reader shared a story about a romantic evening emphasizing the importance of communication and consent.
Swimsuit Issue. The Big Salad swimsuit issue features 18 women's personal recommendations.
Aimee Nezhukumatathil. Poet Aimee Nezhukumatathil discusses her backyard pizza recipe and the coolest hotel.
Ilana Glazer Interview. Comedian/actor Ilana Glazer talks about her new movie, Babes, and how to kick off steamy sex.
Read Further. Over my 20+ years in NYC, I’ve figured out a few ways to deepen friendships.
Favorite Date Spot. Peyton often goes to Rhodora, a wine bar, for her dates to easily manage her exit.
Podcast Co-hosts. Peyton Dix co-hosts 'Lemme Say This', a new pop-culture podcast with Hunter Harris.
Summer Bucket List. We asked 20 people to share fun ideas for soaking up sunshine and good vibes.
Perfect Poolside Drink. Recently my friend Jeni served me a Hugo Spritz, made with Prosecco and St-Germain.
Favorite Market. The farmer's markets, especially the one in Logan Square, are excellent.
Family Dinner Ritual. We grab snacks and beers and pack them in this giant lightweight tote. It can get sandy and wet, is easy to clean.
Cool Summer Treat. To cool off, I go to Steve's Authentic in Red Hook for a 'swingle' - chocolate-covered key lime pie on a POPSICLE STICK.
Family Spotify Playlists. The choices are funny and specific to them, and a big bonus is that I now have a record of their musical tastes each year of their childhood.
Date Preparation. Here are a few texts I exchanged with friends, while I was getting ready for dates or actually ON them.
Debriefing Experiences. "Sometimes the debrief of an event is better than the event itself," says Carla Bezanson.
Purchase Information. For more details and to purchase tickets, go to: https://www.siff.net/cinema/in-theaters/big-salad-comes-to-seattle
Event Details. We’re excited to invite you to an evening in Seattle with Joanna Goddard, Kate Baer, and the Big Salad team.
Dress Style. Tea dresses are best to wear with unexpected shoes, like white Converse high tops.
New TV Series. Gemma's sexy new TV series My Lady Jane just dropped on Amazon.
Catherine Newman Featured. We’re featuring Catherine Newman!!!! The brilliant author writes books about parenting, marriage, aging, and friendship that make us laugh and cry.
Loved Footwear. 'I wear Oofos clogs all day, every day. They cured my plantar fasciitis.'
Podcast Recommendation. 'We’ve been listening to a podcast called Dead Eyes... it’s the most healing thing.'
Catherine's New Novel. 'Catherine’s new novel, Sandwich, offers a hilarious yet tender snapshot of a family vacation.'
New Non-Drinker Favorite. 'I am pretty much obsessed with Trader Joe’s Jalapeño Limeade, which makes the best N/A margarita around.'
Family Connection Ritual. 'Every day on our family group chat, we all share the results for the NYT Strands word-search puzzle... It’s just this connection. Proof of life.'